Disgraceful article!

Status
Not open for further replies.

CharlieH

Teenage Guinea Pig
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
765
Reaction score
111
Points
425
Location
Herefordshire, UK
[Sorry if this has been posted in the past, I did do a search but couldn't find anything!]


I know this is over 2 years old, but I stumbled upon it earlier.

Made me really angry and I thought I would post to see if it was just me being sensitive lol!

http://www.salisburyjournal.co.uk/b.../8122073.Six_reasons_not_to_buy_a_guinea_pig/

My personal curiosity of the article is the fact that she bought guineas for her two year old and then had the cheek to write

The child will become negligent. Hutch cleaning will quickly become your responsibility and finding additional man hours and money is essential.

Anyhow.

Stupid woman.

If comments weren't closed and it was newer, I'd give a little piece of my mind...

Thoughts?
 
Absolutely disgusting, if that is the height of how she puts her journalistic skills to work I pity her. Such a pointless article. Made my blood boil just reading it.
 
oh dear shes not an animal lover is she.... I think the comments at the end from Jo Bloggs public are just as shocking. They are such beautiful, inquisitive creatures and it saddens me that people can talk about animals in such a horrible way.
 
I just think the opinions shared in the article and comments are the epitome of why people shouldn't own animals.

You should have to have a licence or something. Like you used to have to have a dog licence.

[I know it would just create a black market etc and wouldn't really work nowadays, but ideally!]
 
if you read her other storys,you would see,she writes lite hearted,togue in cheek,after all who would spent over £300 on vets fees for a rodent? if they did,nt like animals.l won,nt.
 
It's the first time Ive seen that article and it made me so angry.
What a hard heartless woman she is-I'm surprised she's even a mother being as cold as she comes across in that article.
She obviously knows nothing and its people like her that shouldn't be allowed to have ANY pet.
 
While I don't advocate what she says, you have to remember that she's writing for a specific audience, to earn a living. Sensationalising is used for effect in the media hence the way the article is written.
 
While I don't advocate what she says, you have to remember that she's writing for a specific audience, to earn a living. Sensationalising is used for effect in the media hence the way the article is written.

You are absolutely right sensationalism at it best. As you read through the article it is blatently obvious that many of her facts are indeed fictional. As the article only got two replies it looks like there may be hope for mankind after all and the public saw right through that article.

Most of us are aware on the forum the lengths that rescues go to ensure that any adopted piggies go to a home where they will be cared for properly, informing them of all piggies needs and the amount of time and effort that is required to care for them. Any rescue that we've seen makes sure that it is an adult that is responsible for the care of the piggies. I know of some rescues that will not rehome piggies to families that have very young children without some serious questions being answered, after all the welfare of these piggies is paramount.

The farmer who allegedly sold these piggies to the so called reporter is unfortunately not too uncommon and various pet shops are just as bad. We are in no way lecturing anyone but whilst there is a fast buck to be made the work of rescues will continue to increase until the revolution, when the piggies will rise up and put an end to the continuing perpetuation of breeding, selling and abandonment of piggies. We watched a short video on the NEGPR website about rescue piggies brought into them and it makes us so angry that any so called human being can treat any animal with such contempt.

Thats our rant over!

Lisa & Ali xx
 
To be honest I've learnt to take such ignorance or snide remarks in jest. The fact is no matter how much people wish to believe that they are animal lovers, the majority are not. If we lived in a country of animal lovers it wouldn't be so damn difficult for animal welfare to be acted upon. Instead most sick minded people get away with the abuse and torture they inflict, not to mention places like pets at home who openly recommend a size 100 cage for a rabbit. People like to think they love animals just because they don't harm them 'directly', when in fact most of them use 'pets' as toys and forget about them in no time at all. My animals aren't pets, they're my family and some of them are even like my children, some think I'm mad but they don't see the love and enrichment living with another creature can bring. The diversity of life on this planet should be celebrated, instead people prefer to turn the other way and look down upon them just because they don't communicate in the same way we do. They don't know what they're missing!
 
Last edited:
I understand its for sensationalism but a true animal lover wouldn't want to come across as such a heartless cow in order to get attention.
 
Most people who are heartless towards animals are also the same towards children. Anything weak and defenceless is an easy target. I can't understand the mentality of these people, not so much the author as she's probably doing it to sell as others have said, however her target audience are definitely these kinds of people! I can understand people who aren't crazy about animals, and don't choose to keep them however anyone who deliberately neglects them are evil pieces of rubbish, much like the guy in the comments who is talking about his guinea pig dying in a humorous fashion. Even Ian Brady started out by torturing cats.
 
Horrible article, even if it is for sensationallism.

One thing I can hope is that any people who read this and believe her at least won't get these guinea pigs as pets and more loving owners will get them instead.

I still want to throw rotten tomatoes at her and the comment writers though.
 
I don't know why people are getting so upset about it to be honest. It's an article written for effect from a specific viewpoint for a certain audience.

I'm an animal lover; I'm particularly fond of dogs, however I could easily write an equally, if not more eyebrow raising article about some breeds of dog. It's not like she's advocating harming pigs, or anything outrageous, she's just expressing her opinion with a certain type of brash humour.

It's just an opinion at the end of the day. Just because it doesn't match yours, there's no point in getting angry or upset, there are many more things worthy of your anger going on in the world right now.
 
Last edited:
The only thing I dislike about the article is the misinformation and the fact she keeps using the word 'rodents' in a derogatory manor, even 'feral rodents' at the end. What would people think of me if I expressed a view that she's a nauseating, spiteful excuse for a human being and I believe instead of using innocent animals for scientific research, as she picked up on, I believe we should use people like her. They are of no use to me, much like the guinea pig wasn't to her.
 
The only thing I dislike about the article is the misinformation and the fact she keeps using the word 'rodents' in a derogatory manor, even 'feral rodents' at the end. What would people think of me if I expressed a view that she's a nauseating, spiteful excuse for a human being and I believe instead of using innocent animals for scientific research, as she picked up on, I believe we should use people like her. They are of no use to me, much like the guinea pig wasn't to her.

If you look past the emotive language, she actually raises some important points, that I think we would all agree on.

One: they die all the time.Why? Because they are fragile. They are faddy eaters and need a constant supply of hay, vegetables, and vitamin C or their complex digestive systems will stop working.

True

Two: they hate temperature change. Anything warmer than 80 degrees and they can boil to death; anything colder than five degrees and they will freeze.

True - Any prospective owners should make provisions for both extremes of temperature, which I'm sure most people who pop down to their local pet shop and impulse buy a few pigs and a cheap hutch to shove down the bottom of the garden, don't.

Three: their airways are sensitive. Strong aromas can irritate their lungs, causing some weird form of guinea pig asthma.

Again, true

Four: they get mange mites. Your fluffy pet will become bald and scabby overnight and become prone to seizures.

Another "true", not to mention fungal infections, both of which can be passed to the rest of the family and other animals, and lice.

Five: their teeth are another hazard – if they get too long, they can grow together and the guinea pig will starve to death.

Something that people who don't do their research, are oblivious to. Again, impulse buyers that get animals from pet stores that maybe aren't as healthy, or haven't been given the right diet can be totally unaware of

Six: guinea pigs get stressed. Loud noises and other animals scare them.

Again, true - so maybe it's not best to put your new bundles of joy in your child/ren's bedroom etc.

Snowy ended up in intensive care. Three days later clutching guinea pig drugs, a pipette and the bill, which had reached £372, I brought Snowy home, where she slept by the fire requiring fourhourly feeds. A week later she died in her sleep

Another valid point, as with the one about the mites. Far too many people see guinea pigs and other small rodents (oh no! that word again! well they ARE rodents!) as disposable pets. It's the old "why spend X amount on vets bills when you can go down to P@H and buy 10 for that amount?" argument, which sadly, some owners do have. I think this is the most important point for me; that guinea pigs can, and do, incur vets bills as high as that of a cat or dog.

Another problem with guinea pigs is that they need to be around other guinea pigs. I had to buy more.

Another valid point.


If this woman really didn't like the guinea pigs, would she have forked out for the vets bills? Would she have done the 4 hourly feeds? (Anyone who has done this knows how greulling it is). Would she have got new pigs when previous ones died? She could easily have signed them over to a rescue or put them on free ads as free to a good home.


Personally, I think the article has a lot of valid points that, as I'm sure you'd agree, a lot of guinea pig owners should, and would benefit from, taking on board.
 
Like I've said, I dislike the way she speaks about the pigs, I wasn't discrediting the whole article. The fact is though she has expressed her feelings towards the creatures in the last sentence. It's the target audience, such as the one man in the comments that my major problem is with. I do agree with you though that it's wasted anger, people wont change their minds about animals in general if they don't like them. I just wish they would stop buying them, in that case everyone should be happy.
 
If she really hated the guinea pigs then why did she spend so much money on them. I feel sorry for the poor guinea pigs as she clearly hates them, especially when 'luckily' they dissapeared.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top