• You can find lots of information on how to settle in, understand your new guinea pigs in our New Owners Guide Collection but please ask any questions you have in Wannabe and New Owners' section.

Why Are Guinea Shows Looked Down Upon On Here?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ayla

Junior Guinea Pig
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
328
Likes
222
Points
290
Location
United States
#1
just out of curiosity i've seen a few videos online for guinea pig shows and haven't seen anything cruel, then on here i've seen that shows are not to be discussed. why is that? i disagree with the clothes completely if they do.
 

Lilly

Forum Buddy
Joined
Feb 14, 2012
Messages
4,867
Likes
2,332
Points
970
Location
Brisbane QLD Australia
#3
I think @Flutterby is right. I went to a piggy club show with my granddaughters once, not knowing anything about them. There were breeders there showing their piggies and handing out their cards for people to buy their pigs. We now go to a rescue up the coast instead that has a piggy open day once a month. People show their own pets in fun categories like biggest nose, cutest ears, for a small fee. Also your piggies can get a groom for a small fee - I get the boys' nails cut whenever we go. The rescue raises money in this way and everyone has fun admiring each others' pigs.
 

Goth Mummy

Adult Guinea Pig
Joined
Oct 11, 2013
Messages
4,170
Likes
2,909
Points
1,025
Location
Nottingham
#6
I think its because breeding for showing creates "wastage" in that the pigs that are not considered show standard are valueless for their intended purpose and that puts even more unwanted piggies into the already over crowded piggies-looking-for-homes market?

I'm the same as Treacle, hate dog shows but used to take my rescue greyhound to rescue greyhound events and the Dogs Trust shows, (he once won "most soulful eyes"!) but those are often more of a publicity thing to interest the general dog owning public to encourage adoption not buying puppies.

I dont know how the "forum mods" feel about animal charity fun shows to be honest, I'm sure they will tell us ;).
 

Treacle

Teenage Guinea Pig
Joined
Aug 10, 2014
Messages
740
Likes
692
Points
500
Location
East Midlands, UK
#8
I think its because breeding for showing creates "wastage" in that the pigs that are not considered show standard are valueless for their intended purpose and that puts even more unwanted piggies into the already over crowded piggies-looking-for-homes market?

I'm the same as Treacle, hate dog shows but used to take my rescue greyhound to rescue greyhound events and the Dogs Trust shows, (he once won "most soulful eyes"!) but those are often more of a publicity thing to interest the general dog owning public to encourage adoption not buying puppies.

I dont know how the "forum mods" feel about animal charity fun shows to be honest, I'm sure they will tell us ;).
With my old set up, I used to take in old breeding stock females and non show standard female piggies, I paid for them, less then the going rate for what they were. Unfortunately, the breeder was a cow, I was due to collect a couple of piggies, but broke my wrist, she hounded me by text for 8 weeks, in the end I told her to get stuffed. She just wanted the money.
She did give me ASBO, a young breeding female, who was put in with a prize boar, and she barbered all his fur off over night! Bless! One for girl piggies rights! We did think she might be pregnant, but she wasn't! The boar must have been petrified of her!
 

Veggies Galore

Rescue Buddy
Forum Donator 2017/18
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
10,581
Likes
10,784
Points
2,125
Location
South Yorkshire, UK
#9
With my old set up, I used to take in old breeding stock females and non show standard female piggies, I paid for them, less then the going rate for what they were. Unfortunately, the breeder was a cow, I was due to collect a couple of piggies, but broke my wrist, she hounded me by text for 8 weeks, in the end I told her to get stuffed. She just wanted the money.
She did give me ASBO, a young breeding female, who was put in with a prize boar, and she barbered all his fur off over night! Bless! One for girl piggies rights! We did think she might be pregnant, but she wasn't! The boar must have been petrified of her!

Girl power !
 

Ayla

Junior Guinea Pig
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
328
Likes
222
Points
290
Location
United States
#11
I posted that when I saw a friendly video of one on YouTube then as more and it,just made me sad it kinda just seemed like a nice thing to meet others but I had no idea so my bad on that see why they're frowned upon
 

kayelljay

Junior Guinea Pig
Joined
Sep 23, 2013
Messages
118
Likes
73
Points
270
Location
Chorley, Lancashire
#12
I think it depends on the show its self. There are shows that only care about breeding 'the best' piggies and stuff like that which are just ridiculous - all piggies are gorgeous! It would be nice to see more piggie events that arent about 'showing' your pig, but rather going to meet other people with piggies, buying lovely items for them (including people setting up their own stalls to sell their handmade items), getting them pampered/groomed and raising awareness of rescues/charities that help piggies. Its sad that we don't have more of that.
 

Veggies Galore

Rescue Buddy
Forum Donator 2017/18
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
10,581
Likes
10,784
Points
2,125
Location
South Yorkshire, UK
#13
I think it depends on the show its self. There are shows that only care about breeding 'the best' piggies and stuff like that which are just ridiculous - all piggies are gorgeous! It would be nice to see more piggie events that arent about 'showing' your pig, but rather going to meet other people with piggies, buying lovely items for them (including people setting up their own stalls to sell their handmade items), getting them pampered/groomed and raising awareness of rescues/charities that help piggies. Its sad that we don't have more of that.

I agree. Last April, I went to Cavy Corner's Fun Day and that was exactly what this day was about .

http://www.cavycorner.org/2014 Fun Day.html

I still look upon myself as a newbie and I learnt loads. I watched Winston syringe feed Snowpig and I bought lots lovely new things for my guinea pigs.
 

Wiebke

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Mar 10, 2009
Messages
59,003
Likes
24,148
Points
3,340
Location
Coventry UK
#14
A local fun or charity pet "show" with competition categories like 'who is the fastest eater' is something completely different from professional breeding shows for perfect piggies.

If you want to take part at a local pet show, please make sure that your piggies are confident enough to cope with the stress of being out of their usual surroundings, the general hubbub and with being handled by strangers; the interests and welfare of your piggies should be paramount, not your own desire for a bit of fun!
Cavy Corner Sanctuary for instance take great care that only piggies who are fine with this go with them to events, to schools for education purposes or to care homes. They have got a network of volunteers who handle and cuddle the Sanctuary piggies to make sure that all get regular human attention.

The second category of pedigree shows unfortunately creates a tier of piggies that are not up to standard and that often end up as neglected second class citizens or being sold without any care for what kind of home they go to. This often gets even worse for no longer needed breeding sows or stud boars.
Professional breeders are mainly there for business/selling and not for the sake of animal welfare purposes. We also do not agree with some professional showing practices like forcing long-haired piggies to live with curlers in order to keep their coat pristine nor with the often far too small cubicles in which they are kept all their life long, as well as the way they are often ripped in and out of any established bonds without any consideration for guinea pig instinct and social protocols.
We are well aware that there are some very caring and welfare-conscious people amongst the breeders and have no truck with them whatsoever, but in our and their own experience they are sadly still very much a minority. Animal welfare is something that needs to be as urgently discussed and redefined on the breeding side (who so far seem only concerned with showing standards, but not so much with how they are achieved) as do rescue standards and the need for licensing on the rescue side. As long as there are no clear rules and standards of care, we have to draw our own lines as a forum.

Sadly, several good standard small guinea pig rescues have been brought to the brink or beyond by having job lots of no longer wanted and often pregnant/neglected breeder piggies dumped on them, often with them being lied to or even openly abused by unscrupulous people eager to unload.
The latest victim of that is a RNGP Welfare in Rugby which was the only rescue with a spaying policy in the UK and which did a great service to mainly older bereaved or young unbondable boars all over the country, but which closed down at the beginning of this year after finding a lot cardboard boxes with 16 mostly pregnant sows and 5 boars dumped on their drive one Sunday morning - they ended up with well over 30 babies (and a deadborn/dying baby in nearly every litter) in the end and struggled especially to find homes for all the white/pink-eyed boys. This was sadly the straw that broke the camel's back after all mums and babies were found new homes... :(

Unfortunately, we have made the experience as a forum that whenever we have a line somewhere in the middle, it gets inevitably poked at. Breeding and showing are areas that many people are passionate about, and we have had very heated discussions in the past, which have created a tense general atmosphere on the forum and caused unhappy/upset members to withdraw or leave. Hence our "zero" stance.

@lisaali
 
Last edited:

LisaAli

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Jul 15, 2012
Messages
7,149
Likes
6,153
Points
1,675
Location
Fife
#15
Just to add to what @Wiebke has said.

One of the forum rules states that:-

No member should discuss 'showing' in regards to club/breeder shows as this is against the forum ethos.

Maybe a small clarification is needed with respect to the forum rule - it is meant primarily in that the Forum does not allow the promotion of any pet event whose main function is the promotion and showing/breeding of guinea pigs.

Some rescues will advertise their open days as 'shows' in order to attract the general public. They're actually not 'shows' at all, as stated above the issue is with the club/breeder specific shows - perhaps some of us don't realise there's a difference?

On the forum we differentiate between fun pet shows, taking into consideration what @Wiebke has said in the above post, especially for charity, where all piggies are included and pedigree shows where the aim is to judge the best, creating inevitably a category of "not good enough", which sadly often means, unwanted and not worth being properly cared for.

Below is an actual post on a Facebook page which highlights the world behind the scenes with regard to Guinea Pig Showing.

Would anyone be interested is giving a disabled guinea pig a loving home? He's a loving friendly guy, from show stock, who was dumped back on the doorstep of the breeder around 5 weeks ago along with a little female. He has a head tilt, probably due to an inner ear infection which was left untreated for too long leaving permanent damage.

Lisa & Ali..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top