So rat poison would also pose a risk to other garden animals, such as birds, hedgehogs, local cats etc?
.
I hadn't intended to spend the afternoon researching this topic but you have made some good points and given me cause for concern about my local wildlife.
Apparently humans are always no more than one metre away from a rat - but the odd one or two is not usually a problem and can be trapped. In the case of a severe rat infestation where trapping is not feasible however I continue to think responsible use of poison is justified.
The level of risk to wildlife depends upon whether you are using first generation rodenticides (including warfarin) or newer second generation rodenticides. The former have a low risk of poisoning non-target species - so as long as direct access to bait is restricted to prevent primary poisoning, there is little risk of secondary (indirect) poisoning from contact with poisoned rodents. One exception is that because guinea pigs are small and graze grass, there is a potential risk to them of secondary poisoning if the grass is covered in rat wee containing warfarin and they consume enough quantity in a short space of time to reach a toxic level.
It is the second generation poisons (superwarfarins) that appear to be the problem for wildlife and unfortunately owing to warfarin resistance, these new chemicals comprise most of our currently available rat poisons The risk (again providing acess to bait is restricted) is mainly to those animals further up the food chain that eat the rats (ie cats, birds of prey, foxes - thankfully not hedgehogs) and the two chemicals most implicated in the past of poisoning wildlife ( flocoumafen and brodifacoum) are now banned from outdoor use and can only be used indoors where it can be shown that the rodents concerned are primarily eating/living within the enclosed structure.
To prevent primary poisoning it is important that access to bait by other animals is restricted. Bait boxes are designed in this way to prevent particularly birds, domestic pets and children gaining access. In my case we put bait in plastic bags adn stuffed it into the entrance burrows of the rat nest - inaccessible to any animal but the rats themselves. Smaller rodents (such as field mice etc) would not go anywhere near a rats nest or somewhere rats are inhabiting (they vacate my compost bins when a rat moves in) so there is no danger they would eat the bait.
I cannot find any data to suggest these 2nd generation poisons are excreted in the urine but I recall that they can be found in small quantity in rat poos (but rat poos are not a food source for wildlife - and have you smelt them yeuk

>>>). The main risk of secondary poisoning is to rat predators - ie cats, foxes, birds of prey. However the 2nd generation poisons only require to be used for a very short time as they act very quickly and therefore this dramatically reduces the exposure risk to wildlife. Also, with reference to scavengers, it is very unusual for a rat to die out in the open from poisoning - they normally die in situ in the burrow...(or shed...or compost bin) although sometimes you find youngsters out in the open that could be scavenged by magpies/cats/foxes. Part of responsible baiting is to patrol for dead bodies and dispose of them properly so they can;t be scavenged.
Thankfully after all this research today, I am relatively confident that I have acted responsibly and haven;t poisoned any of my (welcome and guinea pig-friendly ) garden visitors by my actions.
If the rat population increases again I would do the same thing. Waiting that week for the test results to know whether my piggies would have to be removed and destroyed means the health and welfare of my piggies will always take priority over Mr Fox Mr Rat and Mr Magpie.
Cats would be my biggest concern - but judging from the two feral "ratters" I've had on my property these last 13 years, they tend to "play" rather than "eat" rats (mice may be a different story)..and their toxicity level is significantly higher than dogs.
x